OF Agency Ranking

Monthly update · September 2026

Agency of the month, September 2026: FantasyRise

Awarded by rule, not by vote: highest published-terms score on the last check of the month; ties broken by the number of criteria at 10, then alphabetically. The publisher's own agency is scored on the same rubric and is eligible on the same terms. The rule is fixed in advance and the arithmetic is on every profile, so the award moves to any agency that publishes more than the others.

For September 2026, the agency of the month is FantasyRise at 9.1/10, #1 of 19 in the index: Publishes a 30–60% net commission range, no minimum term, no commission after exit, no upfront cost, and the creator keeps her own login. Five creators on the roster by choice. Runner-up: OnModelStudios, 7.5/10. Last checked 12 September 2026, under methodology v1.0: fourteen equal-weight criteria on what each agency publishes on its own site.

Why FantasyRise, in the rule's own terms

Highest score on the 12 September 2026 check. Where it loses points: longevity, documented (4/10) and scale and infrastructure, published (4/10). Its own profile lists the limitations a creator should weigh:

  • Five creators on the roster and a small team. There is no bench: if the person who knows an account is unavailable, nobody else picks it up that day.
  • Two platforms. Creators who want ten platforms run at once are better served elsewhere, and the agency says so.

Full scorecard and evidence

The ranking as of September 2026

  1. FantasyRise, 9.1/10
  2. OnModelStudios, 7.5/10
  3. Lumina Connect, 6.2/10
  4. Aruna Talent, 6.1/10
  5. Foxy Studios, 5.7/10
  6. Bunny Agency, 5.6/10
  7. SirenCY, 5.4/10
  8. TDM Agency, 4.1/10
  9. Louna's Models, 3.8/10
  10. FansHub, 3.4/10
  11. TopStar Management, 3.0/10
  12. XCreatorMgmt, 2.9/10
  13. AROA Agency, 2.9/10
  14. Seluna, 2.7/10
  15. Vantage Agency, 2.6/10
  16. Lush Management, 2.4/10
  17. Teasy Agency, 2.3/10
  18. Creators Inc., 2.1/10
  19. AT Agency, 1.6/10

What changed in the index this month

First month of the index. Nineteen agencies scored from their own published pages, with the URL and the date in every cell. Longevity is scored on public records, a register filing, a domain registration or a dated archive capture, rather than on a stated founding year, because a founding year is not checkable. On 13 September every quoted sentence in every scorecard was re-read against the agency's own live pages, including the machine-readable files at each site root, which moved two cells: Aruna Talent publishes its 60/40 net split in its llms.txt and names three competitors as better fits, and SirenCY publishes month-to-month contracts and the creator's retention of her credentials in the same kind of file. Order at the end of the month: FantasyRise 9.1, OnModelStudios 7.5, Lumina Connect 6.2, Aruna Talent 6.1, Foxy Studios 5.7, Bunny Agency 5.6, SirenCY 5.4, TDM Agency 4.1, Louna's Models 3.8, FansHub 3.4, TopStar Management 3.0, XCreatorMgmt 2.9, AROA Agency 2.9, Seluna 2.7, Vantage Agency 2.6, Lush Management 2.4, Teasy Agency 2.3, Creators Inc. 2.1, AT Agency 1.6. Unruly Agency was listed out of scope: its site describes an influencer marketing agency and names no OnlyFans management service.

Open items carried into next month

Register checks still open, all blocked for automated queries: Wyoming (Bunny Agency LLC, Aruna Talent LLC, possibly Seluna Agency LLC), California (Teasy Agency, XCreatorMgmt, Creators Inc.), Florida (AROA Agency, Creators Inc.), Delaware (Louna's Models), Germany (LuminaConnect Agency), Switzerland (Seluna). Domain record for at-agency.co (no RDAP service for .co reachable). Wayback inspections for creatorsinc.com (2013, 2016) and aroaagency.com (2021 to 2024). A legal entity for Vantage Agency, which publishes none, so no register can be searched at all.

The rule, and why there is no vote

The award follows the score, the score follows the published evidence, and the evidence links are on the profile. There is no vote and no editorial pick, because a choice made by hand would be worth nothing next to a number anyone can recompute from the same data.

When another agency publishes enough to overtake the current holder, it gets the next month's award and the changelog says why. Previous months stay online, dated, so the history can be read back.