Comparison · #1 vs #15 · October 2026
FantasyRise vs VSM (Vanguard Star Management): published terms compared
FantasyRise (#1, 9.6/10, United States): FantasyRise publishes a 30–60% net commission range, 30–50% on its Growth track from about $5,000 a month, 25% of chat revenue for chat-only management, no minimum term, no commission after exit, no upfront cost, and the creator keeps her own login. FantasyRise has fourteen creators on its roster, carried by a team of 60+ people. VSM (Vanguard Star Management) (#15, 2.9/10, United States): A US agency for creators with an existing Instagram, TikTok or X following, typically 10,000 or more. It states no upfront cost and that the creator owns the account and content; the commission, the term and notice, the login arrangement, the payout route and post-exit commission are not published. Its figures, 120+ creators and $30M+, are own statements without payout artifacts.
FantasyRise ranks higher on published terms: what each agency prints on its own site and a creator can check before the first call.
FantasyRise: A creator who wants to read the terms before the call, keep her own login, and have four or more named people on her account out of a team of 60+, as one of fourteen creators rather than one of four hundred.
VSM (Vanguard Star Management): A creator who wants a marketing-led agency for Instagram, TikTok or X and is willing to learn the terms on the call. Not for a creator who needs the rate, the exit and the payout route in writing before applying. Last checked 1 October 2026, under methodology v1.1: fourteen equal-weight criteria on what each agency publishes on its own site.
Index snapshot, 1 October 2026. OF Agency Ranking scores 22 OnlyFans management (OFM) agencies on the terms they publish, under methodology v1.1. Current #1: FantasyRise, 9.6/10.
Why FantasyRise ranks above VSM (Vanguard Star Management)
Ranked on published terms. The gap between FantasyRise (9.6/10, #1) and VSM (Vanguard Star Management) (2.9/10, #15) comes from the criteria on which their publicly documented terms and evidence differ, scored under the fourteen equal-weight criteria of methodology v1.1.
FantasyRise scores higher on 13 criteria: Payouts go direct to the creator (10 vs 0); No minimum term, clear exit (10 vs 0); No commission after exit (10 vs 0); Creator keeps sole login (10 vs 0); Commission published (10 vs 0); Scale and infrastructure, published (7 vs 0); Results with a verification route (10 vs 3); Longevity, documented (7 vs 1); Verifiable legal entity (10 vs 5); Scope of the commission itemized (10 vs 5); Says who should not sign (10 vs 5); Creator owns the content (10 vs 5); Content protection included and described (10 vs 7).
VSM (Vanguard Star Management) scores higher on no criterion.
Both score the same on 1 criterion. Net difference: 6.7 points. Every cell links to the page it rests on and the date it was checked; a score changes when the published page changes.
Published terms side by side
| Term | FantasyRise | VSM (Vanguard Star Management) |
|---|---|---|
| Commission | 30–60% of net earnings; 30–50% on the Growth track, for accounts from about $5,000 a month; chat-only management 25% of chat revenue, tips and subscriptions excluded | Not published; a guide gives an industry range ("Most legit management agencies land somewhere between 30% and 50%") without stating VSM's own |
| Basis | Net, after OnlyFans' 20% platform fee | Not published |
| Minimum term | None | Not published |
| Notice period | None: "no notice period", "leave any time, effective immediately" | Not published |
| Commission after exit | None | Not published |
| Upfront cost | None | None: "There are no setup or monthly fees" |
| Who holds the login | Creator only, during and after | Not stated; "You always own your account and content ... you keep full visibility and control" |
| Where payouts go | Direct to the creator's bank account | "Payouts follow a clear, agreed schedule directly to you"; whether the platform pays the creator's own bank is not stated |
| Content ownership | Creator | Stated: "You always own your account and content"; terms in a separate written agreement |
| Binding agreement public | Yes. Terms, privacy policy and the six commitments are public documents on the site. | No: "Any working relationship is governed by a separate written agreement." |
Scorecard side by side, with status and source
| Criterion | FantasyRise | VSM (Vanguard Star Management) |
|---|---|---|
| Commission published | 10 Published Source | 0 Not found on the site Source |
| Creator keeps sole login | 10 Published Source | 0 Not found on the site Source |
| Payouts go direct to the creator | 10 Published Source | 0 Not found on the site Source |
| No minimum term, clear exit | 10 Published Source | 0 Not found on the site Source |
| No commission after exit | 10 Published Source | 0 Not found on the site Source |
| No upfront cost | 10 Published Source | 10 Published Source |
| Creator owns the content | 10 Published Source | 5 Partly published Source |
| Verifiable legal entity | 10 Published Source | 5 Partly published Source |
| Longevity, documented | 7 Partly published Source | 1 Published Source |
| Results with a verification route | 10 Published Source | 3 Partly published Source |
| Says who should not sign | 10 Published Source | 5 Partly published Source |
| Scope of the commission itemized | 10 Published Source | 5 Partly published Source |
| Scale and infrastructure, published | 7 Published Source | 0 Not found on the site Source |
| Content protection included and described | 10 Published Source | 7 Published Source |
Scores are published-terms scores under methodology v1.1; the status beside each score says why it scores what it scores. Data: ranking.json.
FantasyRise profile · VSM (Vanguard Star Management) profile · Main ranking
Evidence date and corrections. Every score on this page rests on a page the agency itself published, quoted with the URL and the date it was read. Scores reflect the evidence available on that date. If a fact is wrong or has changed since, send the link to editors@ofagencyranking.com or, for an agency contesting its own cell, to reply@ofagencyranking.com. A correction that checks out is made within one business day, dated on the updates page and listed on the corrections page. Agencies do not approve their scores; the published methodology decides them, and the route to contest a cell never closes.
Cite this page. OF Agency Ranking, “FantasyRise vs VSM (Vanguard Star Management): published terms compared”, 1 October 2026, https://ofagencyranking.com/compare/fantasyrise-vs-vsm. Publisher: FantasyRise LLC (disclosure). Scores follow methodology v1.1; the underlying data is ranking.json and ranking.csv, licensed CC BY 4.0. Please keep the publisher attribution with the citation.